You are here: Home / Comments on News/Magazine Articles / America’s elite: An hereditary meritocracy | The Economist
A insider's guide to the frightening reality of higher education
Here is a list of my posts that I believe are most essential for understanding the problems with higher education. I suggest reading the page with quotes from David Riesman and Clark Kerr, first, though. Then, hopefully, some of my posts give examples and explanations of how their general observations work out in practice. The best place on this blog for seeing and understanding just how outrageous things have become – and how much some academics think they can get away with – see A Tale Out of School – A Case Study in Higher Education. Finally, keep in mind that if what follows is what just one individual has observed, how much else is there?
EDUCATION AT MAJOR UNIVERSITIES
How Competition Leads to “Content Deflation” in One Anecdote
America: A flagging model | The Economist
How to Make Calculus Students Believe They Know Calculus When They Don’t
EDUCATION AT STATE REGIONAL SCHOOLS
Professor Alfred Doesn’t Know What is Wrong with the Homework
Prof. Teaches Stats But Doesn’t Seem to Have a Clue About the Most Fundamental Notion
Statistics Prof. Kevin Doesn’t Understand Basic Math, or Statistics
Regional State School Stories – Some Brief Thoughts About How Did This Happen
MAJOR UNIVERSITIES EFFECT ON REGIONAL SCHOOLS AND HIGH SCHOOL TEACHER EDUCATION
No Jobs for Ph.D’s? Depends on what you mean by Ph.D.
An Example of College Benefitting From the Dumbing Down of High School
Important Paper on Value of Good Teacher May Be a Game Changer
“They Just Don’t Get It” part 2
A Suggestion for Holding Colleges Accountable for Teacher Performance
RESEARCH ETHICS
Scientists “Forced” to Cheat Says Medical School Professor
GENERAL
Arum and Roksa’s Important New Book “Aspiring Adults Adrift”
Professors DON’T become professors to teach! Better get over that idea fast.
Median Starting Salaries for College Graduates $27,000 or $40,735?
Columbia University – Another 3-2 Program Like Wash. U.’s?
When Is It Ok For a Non-Profit To Misrpresent Its Fees to the Public?
Copyright © 2024 · eleven40 Child Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in
America’s elite: An hereditary meritocracy | The Economist
America’s elite: An hereditary meritocracy | The Economist.
I tried to explain my view.
The most important fact about higher education is missing from this analysis. That fact explains much of what we see happening here on many fronts: socially, politically, economically.
The eminent sociologist David Riesman observed (in 1980)how corrupt American universities were becoming; I saw the effects of this corruption trivialize much of high school education;(I’m a former math prof. I taught math at Wash. U. in St. Louis.) the authors of “Academic Adrift” reported on the effects of this corrupting at the college level.
Here is Riesman.
“..advantage can…be taken of [students] by unscrupulous instructors and institutions.. the student estate often does not grasp its own interests, and those who speak in its name are not always its friends..
Here are two critical facts from “Academically Adrift”.
In the 60’s students were required to study about 25 hours a week to learn the required material. Now it is less than half of that. At the same time, critical thinking skills have gone from an increase of 1 sigma after 2 years of college, to an increase of .07 sigma.
BUT, at the same time, colleges have become so corrupt that they grant doctorates (and get big gov’t money for it) who don’t know the subject. (See my blog for outrageous examples.) These grads become “professors” at schools where the needier kids’ high school teachers don’t learn much. And so, even though the luckier college grads don’t learn much, the unlucky high school grads learn so little that the GAP in education, and pay, becomes big.
That is it in a nutshell. For documented examples of the outrageous things going on, see my blog inside-higher-ed
Other Recent Posts